The past couple of weeks at home have been spent brainstorming. I was running Windows Vista, but I’m simply not impressed with it. My dual core P4 with 2Gigs of RAm slow down to a crawl sometimes on it, with a 512mb NVidia Geforce 7300 Graphics card slow down toa crawl on it, and its quite disconcerting when that happens. Switched over to Ubuntu 7.10, and was more than impressed by it. Compiz Fusion knocks the living daylights out of Aero. The look and feel of the OS was very, very impressive. I then made the decision to switch over completely to Ubuntu. The overall experience seems so much more stable, and enough eye candy without having to compromise on resources.Unfortunately, I do not think its going to materialise in the long run, even though Ubuntu is a superior OS to MS Windows in many ways. Here’s a few reasons why.
1. The dependence on Windows for average everyday computing is way too much. For example, On Linux, sending a file over a messenger does not seem possible, and even if it does, its pretty darn hard to figure out how.
2. There are way too many applications available, that are Windows only. Linux alternatives for these exists, and though the effort of the developers is very commendable, these alternatives are not as feature rich as the original application. I know Wine exists, but quite a few apps above really have not gelled well with Wine.
3. Syncing Music to a Media Player is a tedious task. On Linux, I can do that easily using Amarok, but Album Art and the likes seem to be a major pain. Amarok, again, is a kazillion times better than Windows Media Player.
4. Firmware updates for my phone can be done only through Windows.
5. My Media Center remote has to be configured to work with MythTV. I’ve downloaded the modules and keymaps, but I’d rather have something that works out of the box.
5. The whole concept of configuring a new Operating System, however technically inclined you are, is an uphill task, that needs investing a lot of time. Unfortunately, thats precisely what I’m lacking.
And then, there a dozen other reasons like if I’m not at home and someone needs to use the PC, they’ll have to spend half an hour figuring out how, assuming I’m running a highly customised Linux.
And hence, that copy of Windows XP home lying around seems very very tempting right now. Everything can be worked out pretty easily, including the Media Center remote, on the excellent open source Media Portal application.
Sadly, Ubuntu, shall have to be reduced to the confines of backup PC, if I ever manage to have one, and get time enough to use it. The world is unjust, or Windows is a villan
Lesson to be learnt :- Thy shall not try to switch over to Linux when thy hath only singular computer at disposal.
10 Comments until now
Yeah. Exactly. Welcome to the club
A small suggestion here…One option…dual boot..but thats kinda lame…so another option is setting up a virtual machine in ur ubuntu system…with xp or vista on it…on vic versa depending on the resource consumption…So take a pic… But then again…this needs time and from the looks of it…you dont have much of that lying around…
I think its completely impossible for anyone to ignore windows and carry on as if nothings wrong. I run a Mac Tiger OS X, an Ubuntu Gutsy Gibbon, a Windows Vista Home Premium and a Windows XP SP2 all under one roof on different systems at home just cuz I can. But here are a few more reasons why Windows is indispensable.
1) A lot of coding and developing is Windows Based…
2) Not a techie? Fine. Even if you’re a marketing specialist and you want to log into your office server from home, a firefox on a ubuntu is just not enough no matter how stable it is. You need the windows IE.
3) If your office has a microsoft outlook based mail service you’ll end up looking like a dead duck the moment u try accessing mail from a Ubuntu or a Mac.
4) Bank Payments Processing Systems are entirely windows based( or at least most of them). Try topping up your prepaid mobile on the bank’s website or try paying a bill on visa billpay dot com on your Ubuntu. Very painful.
Ubuntu is good. Mac is great. But Windows Rules… As much as I hate saying it.
- Tech Na Myte
Well……. If you are not a techie, yes, it’s better to stick to Windows.
I did the switch about a year ago and now I hate to even check my email on a non-linux PC. Linux is equally addictive. Take my word for that.
I do agree that compiz on gnome is cool but it’s almost entirely for NVidia cards (I have seen it behave really weird on my ATI)
If you really want optimized productivity, try KDE. It lets you do almost anything you can imagine.
Further, as most of the “cool” games don’t run on wine, it further keeps you focussed on your goal (unless of course playing games is your goal
)
P.S.
Gtalk (ofc the “talk” part) is the only thing I really miss on Linux….
Hey Alok,
If you really want gtalk on your Linux, why don’t you try Pidgin? You can integrate your yahoo, gtalk, hotmail ids on one account.
I thought pidgin had file transfer.
I went through with the switch from windows to ubuntu about half way then just got pulled back.two things you still cant do in ubuntu…oh well atleast not well or easily…Music recording and games
…Or simply move to a mac
Technamyte,
I already have pidgin and kopete. I have also tried a bunch of other IMClients. I don’t think any of them can be used for voice chats. AFAIK linux-skype is the only s/w that can currently be used for voice chats.
Correct me if I am wrong.
OFC I have heard abt jabbin. But I have never seen it working…
Add your Comment!